Carolyn Schwaar is the former editor of REALTOR® AE magazine.
The Airbnb Factor
How the home-sharing movement is affecting your business.
January 20, 2016
Broker-owner Carla Muss-Jacobs of Buyers Agent Portland is getting a lot of phone calls from a certain kind of buyer lately. Several times a month, people call her Portland, Ore., office looking for properties to turn into Airbnb short-term rentals.
The issues Muss-Jacobs raises with potential clients range from zoning restrictions and second-home property taxes to special insurance coverage and property management costs. But she stresses that she doesn’t offer specific advice. “If someone wants to buy a property and turn it into an Airbnb, I can help identify the best location and the best property, but I couldn’t advise them definitely [by saying] ‘yes, you can do that.’ ”
Airbnb, which matches travelers with property owners who have a couch, a room, or an entire property to rent, has become powerful force in the real estate market. The company began in 2008 as an online platform matching budget travelers with people looking to make money from renting unused space in their homes.
Today Airbnb is a $25.5 billion business. It lists 1.5 million properties in 190 countries. Originally, most listings were offers to share a space with the owner, but now 65 percent are for an entire property, some available 365 days a year, according to Airdna, a research company that analyzes Airbnb data.
Browse Portland’s 2,400 active listings and you’ll find a basement bedroom with a private entrance in a downtown townhouse for $75 a night—and the owner “can have wine or cannabis waiting for you for a small fee.” An entire two-bedroom home in a quiet Portland residential neighborhood fetches $275 a night—the owners live in the house next door and offer to show you around town.
While the short-term rental business has been a flourishing niche, well, since the advent of the vacation, Airbnb, along with sites like HomeAway, VRBO, and Flipkey.com, make it easier and cheaper for consumers to book vacation properties. Meanwhile, property owners or managers can get lodging information in front of millions of potential customers in minutes. Airbnb collects a fee (usually around 3 percent of the rental price) only when an accommodation is rented.
The income potential is luring both home owners and investors to try their hand at being vacation rental entrepreneurs or “hosts,” as Airbnb calls them.
“The buyers I’ve talked to read about Airbnb or maybe traveled to Portland staying in an Airbnb accommodation and thought it was a good way to make money,” says Muss--Jacobs. “They primarily look at lower-end condos, which they want to buy with cash.”
Shifting Short-Term Rental Laws
One challenge in working with buyers interested in listing properties on Airbnb is the fluctuation in local regulations of short-term rentals, typically rentals shorter than 30 days. Cities, towns, and especially resort areas nationwide are rewriting these regulations for a variety of reasons. Some towns hope to benefit from a new tax and license fee revenue stream, while other areas seek to curb the conversion of single-family homes and long-term rental housing stock into transient accommodation. Portland welcomed Airbnb in 2014 by legalizing short-term rentals and striking a deal whereby Airbnb collects and remits lodging taxes on behalf of hosts. The city requires that hosts buy a permit for about $178 a year and have their properties inspected for safety. Portland expects to raise $500,000 a year in tax revenue, the Portland Tribune reported.
The public sentiment toward Airbnb is less enthusiastic in Austin, Texas, which has similar owner requirements as Portland. The city is debating ways to toughen regulations in response to public complaints about Airbnb “party houses” that disrupt the quiet of residential neighborhoods and could potentially lower property values. Austin is considering phasing out short-term rental licensing in some areas, increasing fines for unlicensed rental properties, and prohibiting the use of short-term rentals for gatherings such as bachelor parties, weddings, and concerts, according to the Austin American-Statesman. Officials of San Francisco-based Airbnb declined to be interviewed for this article.
Aiming for even tighter restrictions, San Francisco put forth a ballot initiative in November, sponsored by community groups and the hotel industry that would have given neighbors greater power to sue property owners suspected of violating the law. It also sought to limit the number of days property owners could rent space to just 75 a year—down from the current 90. Voters narrowly defeated the bill. Still, a 2015 ordinance has restricted short-term rentals to owner--occupied properties and requires hosts to register with the city as a business. Airbnb now provides data to the city treasurer about how often homes are being rented out and at what cost so officials can track hosts who are not paying the required taxes.
Though the SFAR board of directors unanimously opposed the city’s most recent attempt to tighten rental restrictions, says Woo, the association worked closely with the city’s planning commission on its earlier ordinance to strike a balance between protecting private property rights and preserving affordable housing.
Effect on Property Values
Under current rules, short-term rentals are illegal in most of Los Angeles. Still, hundreds of listings are posted on Airbnb throughout the city. “An Airbnb next door is a property stigma,” says Nichols. “We should add short-term rentals next door to our property seller disclosure forms.” (Read more about Nichols’ views on the risks posed by Airbnb here.)
5 Things Airbnb-Minded Buyers Should Consider
1. The property must be in an area zoned for short-term rental. Residential neighborhood zoning restrictions may prohibit all rental property or running a business. Airbnb is considered a business.
2. Homeowners associations or condo boards must approve short-term rentals. Condo boards commonly ban renting out individual units, which may also extend to renting rooms in owner-occupied units.
3. Mortgage lenders may require additional insurance coverage for properties that the owner intends to rent out, even when the owner is only renting a part of an owner-occupied home. Lenders will likely not consider potential income from Airbnb when evaluating qualifications for a loan.
4. Not only are property taxes often higher for second-home properties and non–owner-occupied properties, even renting out a room in an owner-occupied property may result in the property being reclassified as a commercial property and taxed as such.
5. In many areas, owners must have licenses or permits and pay occupancy, hotel, or sales taxes to offer short-term rental accommodations.
Muss-Jacobs has a different view, believing Airbnb may help raise property values in Portland. Homes on the market may fetch a higher price if they have “rentable” features—such as a finished basement with its own entrance—or are already established as licensed and profitable Airbnb enterprises, she says.
Short-term rentals—typically family vacations stays—are an important pipeline for housing sales in her lakeside area. “People come and try the community by renting a home on the lake or on the golf course for a vacation, then decide to buy,” says DuFort.
Had county commissioners in DuFort’s area restricted short-term rentals as proposed in 2015, property values would have dropped, she says. “Our opportunity to sell vacation and second homes would have been reduced and some of us involved in property management would have seen that business go away.” DuFort and her local REALTOR® association were able to convince the county that Airbnb and similar platforms posed no threat to the quality of life in the area.
Effect on Second-Home Market
Practitioners who specialize in second homes, resort, and vacation properties are now faced with a more savvy buyer because of Airbnb, says Holly Mabery, RSPS, SRS, an agent with Realty One Group Mountain Desert in Sedona, Ariz. “Traditionally, short-term rentals were held behind the magic curtain, and you had to work with an agent who specialized in them to get a feel for values and return on investment,” she says. “Now, with Airbnb and VRBO, that curtain is gone.” Airbnb posts rental prices, service fees, and taxes for its listings, making it easier for investors to see the competition in the area and what the market will bear.
Vacation home sales jumped 57 percent in 2014, reaching their highest levels since NAR began tracking them in 2003. While the connection between the online platforms and the sales increase is hard to quantify, it’s clear consumers are viewing real estate through a new lens. “The ways in which people can use their property have become broader and it gives me a new tool to use when I’m strategizing with clients over their real estate portfolio,” Mabery says. “Some clients have actually been able to buy up because of the Airbnb effect.”
Still, agents working with Airbnb-minded clients face a range of complicating issues.“[Consumers] need to know the true costs of a rental—provided their property is legally rentable in the first place,” says Mabery. For example, “they need to invest in higher-end appliances and good bedding. They can’t just go to Goodwill and furnish a vacation rental.” Buyers must consider turnover costs and maintenance and calculate the cost of nights not rented, she adds. “That’s a huge mind shift for people just putting their toe in the water of short-term rentals.”
Airbnb insists in public statements that it wants to be a good neighbor as its role in the sharing economy evolves. Still, communities are split on its merits. While some home owners fume over the “hotelization” of neighborhoods, others need the rent from their spare rooms—or entire home while they’re away—to pay their mortgages. As municipalities debate new rules addressing the obligations of online platforms, real estate pros can play an important role in helping clients understand the state of play in their markets.
Updated: October 15, 2021